All But Redacted: The Privileges or Immunities Clause | Episode 3
Podcast (bound-by-oath): Play in new window | Download
[Click here for Episode 1. And click here for Episode 2.]
The Privileges or Immunities Clause was meant to be one of the key liberty-protecting provisions of the Fourteenth Amendment. The Clause says: “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States.” That sounds like a big deal, right? It’s not. The Clause has been virtually read out of the Constitution, and for people trying to vindicate their civil rights in court, it’s been of little practical use. That story—the near redaction of the Clause—begins with the Slaughterhouse Cases, which the U.S. Supreme Court decided in 1873.
On Episode Three of Bound By Oath: What rights were the Framers of the Fourteenth Amendment seeking to protect through the Privileges or Immunities Clause? And what happened to the Clause?
Click here for transcript.
Click for iTunes, Spotify, Google Podcasts, TuneIn, and Stitcher.
Guests
Chris Green, University of Mississippi School of Law
Randy Barnett, Georgetown Law
With appearances by:
Kurt Lash, University of Richmond School of Law
Aderson Francois, Georgetown Law
Martha Jones, Johns Hopkins University
Josh Blackman, South Texas College of Law Houston
Sheldon Gilbert, National Constitution Center
Resources
C-SPAN Coverage of Professor Barnett’s talk on Slaughterhouse at the U.S. Supreme Court Historical Society.
C-SPAN Coverage of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg at Georgetown Law Center’s mock retrial of Bradwell v. Illinois.
Bench Memo for the Re-argument of The Slaughter-House Cases, by Nicholas Mosvick
The Slaughterhouse Cases: Regulation, Reconstruction, and the Fourteenth Amendment, by Ronald M. Labbé and Jonathan Lurie
Equal Citizenship, Civil Rights, and the Constitution: The Original Sense of the Privileges or Immunities Clause, by Chris Green
Interracial Marriage and the Original Understanding of the Privileges or Immunities Clause, by David Upham
From Antislavery Lawyer to Chief Justice: The Remarkable but Forgotten Career of Salmon P. Chase, by Randy Barnett
Recent Episodes
Neat Takings Tricks | Season 3, Ep. 13
The Fifth Amendment says that the government must pay just compensation when it takes private property for public use, a command that, regrettably, is often […]
Listen NowTrust But Verify | Season 3, Ep. 12
In 1973, federal narcotics agents raided a pair of homes in Collinsville, Illinois by mistake. They didn’t find any drugs, but they did terrorize two […]
Listen NowEverything You Eat, Drink, and Wear | Season 3, Ep. 11
Government officials must obtain a warrant before forcibly entering a home (absent consent or an emergency). That rule goes back to the Founding. But in […]
Listen NowSpecial Weapons and Tactics | Season 3, Ep. 10
In 2020, a police SWAT team blew up Vicki Baker’s house after a fugitive barricaded himself inside. On this episode, we ask: who pays the […]
Listen Now