Cars and free speech, what could be a more American combination? This week we’re playing a double-sided session that you can enjoy while honking your horn or writing your Facebook post. That’s because our two cases examine the free-speech implications of both of those activities. First, if you honk in support of a protest, is that protected by the First Amendment? We drive out to sunny California and the Ninth Circuit to answer that automotive question. Then, it’s off to the hills of Kentucky for another—not quite as fun—car activity: Calling the tow truck. For one towing company they found the calls stopped just around the time they criticized a local politician on Facebook. Coincidence? The Sixth Circuit thinks maybe not. Plus, with a speech bonus, you’ll hear what Rudyard Kipling thought of the motorcar.

Porter v. Martinez

Lemaster v. Lawrence County

To Motorists

Background to To Motorists

Recent Episodes

May 25, 2023

Short Circuit 273 | Suing to Apportion Seats

Today we’re digging into the Fourteenth Amendment. No, not the part we usually talk about, Section 1, with its privileges or immunities, equal protection, and […]

Read More

May 18, 2023

Short Circuit 272 | Elizabeth Warren and Jackets

If a sitting senator threatened you with censorship, would it matter what jacket she’s wearing? Although not an issue we discuss this week, it’s related […]

Read More

May 05, 2023

Short Circuit 270 | Baby Ninth Amendments

IJ attorney Josh Windham seizes the microphone and turns it around on your regular host, Anthony Sanders. Josh interviews Anthony about his new book, which […]

Read More

April 27, 2023

Short Circuit 269 | The British Constitution

It’s Special Short Circuit time. And this time that means we don’t just investigate a special legal issue, we journey to a special place (well, […]

Read More