Court of Appeals Will Rule on Federal Accountability in Case Involving Detention of Protest Apparel
SAN FRANCISCO—Tomorrow, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals will hear oral argument in a case asking whether state law can provide damages remedies for federal officials’ constitutional violations. The case was brought by entrepreneur and activist René Quiñonez, arising from the seizure and detention of his protest apparel in the summer of 2020. The United States District Court for the Northern District of California held that Quiñonez and his small family business, Movement Ink LLC, have no path to accountability, no matter how egregiously federal law enforcement violated his First and Fourth Amendment rights. Represented by the Institute for Justice (IJ), Quiñonez will ask the Court of Appeals to recognize the availability of state-law remedies for those rights violations.
“Federal officials cannot violate rights with impunity,” said IJ Attorney Jaba Tsitsuashvili. “That’s never been America’s legal regime, and it can’t be now. Recent events shine a light on what happens when federal officers are emboldened to believe they’re above the law. This case is an opportunity for the judiciary to do what it’s always done: uphold the rule of law. That includes recognizing the availability of traditional state-law remedies to vindicate constitutional rights.”
The case spun out of the nationwide protests against police brutality during the summer of 2020. Movement Ink, a small screen-printing business run by Quiñonez and his family in Oakland, California, received orders for thousands of cloth facemasks emblazoned with protest speech, such as “Stop Killing Black People.” Quiñonez shipped the packages from the same post office he typically used, where the activist nature of his screen-printing business was well known. But instead of receiving their protest apparel, Movement Ink’s customers received notifications that the packages—containing nothing but cloth masks—had been “seized by law enforcement.”
After years of litigation, the federal government could not identify a reason to suspect Movement Ink, Mr. Quiñonez, their customers, or the packages of anything unlawful, either for the postal worker who diverted the packages or the federal law enforcement officers who detained the packages. Yet the district court held that federal law provides no route to accountability for those unconstitutional detentions.
The court also held that federal officials are absolutely immune from any state-law remedies. But state-law remedies are how Americans have traditionally vindicated their rights against abusive federal officials. As federal officials increasingly violate individuals’ rights with no meaningful federal oversight or accountability, the judiciary cannot erect an unprecedent immunity from states’ prerogative to provide their residents with legal avenues for redress. California law provides that avenue, including via the state’s Bane Act, its more recent No Kings Act, and via traditional tort remedies.
“Our constitutional rights mean little if they can be violated without any remedy,” said IJ Senior Attorney Patrick Jaicomo.
Since the beginning of the case, national attention has continued to grow over federal officers’ violations of Americans’ rights with no accountability. IJ has been a national leader in ensuring that such abuses can be remedied. Through its Project on Immunity and Accountability, IJ seeks to ensure that every right guaranteed by the Constitution has a remedy in an American court. And through its Project on the Fourth Amendment, IJ seeks to protect our right to be secure in our persons and property. IJ has successfully argued before the Supreme Court on behalf of an Atlanta family whose home was wrongly raided by an FBI SWAT team. IJ filed a lawsuit on behalf of an Arizona grandmother wrongly arrested by U.S. Marshals. And IJ secured a victory against the federal government’s policy of unconstitutionally raiding private construction sites and rounding up construction workers without suspicion.
# # #
To arrange interviews on this subject, journalists may contact Phillip Suderman, IJ’s Communications Project Manager, at [email protected] or (850) 376-4110. More information on the case is available at: https://ij.org/case/oakland-mail-seizure/
More News
Commercial Speech
Victory: FDA Agrees to Stop Banning Truthful ‘Low-FODMAP’ Food Labels
Housing Abundance and Affordability
Idaho Supreme Court: Property Owners Cannot Challenge Meridian’s Ban on Tiny Homes on Wheels
Education Entrepreneurship
