Delaware

Delaware

Final grade: B

Exclusion Grade

B

Relevance Grade

B-

Due Process Grade

B

Strengths

  • Repealed multiple good moral character requirements for its licenses, though it did not enact an overarching ban.

Areas of Improvement

  • Require evidence of rehabilitation when considering applicants.
  • Strengthen safeguards for due process by requiring a petition process and placing the burden of proof on the state.

Delaware receives a D- for its overall lackluster protections for ex-offenders seeking licenses. Unlike many other states, Delaware requires people with criminal records to obtain a waiver before they can obtain a license, but those with felony convictions generally must wait at least five years before they can apply for such a waiver. However, for a select number of licenses, including barbers, cosmetologists, electricians, massage therapists, and construction contractors, the waiting period is reduced to three years for felonies against a person, and two years for all other felonies. In addition, for those same select licenses, boards may not consider convictions older than 10 years.

Rather confusingly, Delaware defines its “substantially related” standard as “the nature of the criminal conduct, for which the person was convicted” that has “a direct bearing on the fitness or ability to perform one or more of the duties or responsibilities necessarily related.” (The state’s limited case law did not elaborate on the “direct bearing” aspect.) For the purposes of this report, Delaware is graded as having a “substantially related” standard.

Statute: Del. Code Ann. tit.24, §§ 101 – 5515 (2019)

Exclusion
Overarching ban on blanket bans Yes
Ban on considering arrest records Yes
Ban on considering post-conviction relief records No
Time limit No limit
Ban on vague, discretionary character standards No, but the state repealed moral character requirements for multiple licenses
Relevance
Relationship between the crime and the license sought "Substantially related"
Required factors for consideration
Rehabilitation No
Time elapsed since crime was committed No
Age when crime was committed No
Employment History No
Testimonials No
Due Process
Petition Process No
Burden of Proof Both unspecified
Right to appeal Yes
Written notice requirement No