We celebrate, and dig into, two victories for property rights this week—both in IJ cases! First, IJ’s Wesley Hottot discusses the Sixth Circuit’s opinion in his clients’ challenge to Detroit’s vehicle seizure program. Wayne County, Michigan will seize cars on flimsy grounds and then wait months until the owner can even try and get the car back—unless you fork over some ransom money, in which case it doesn’t matter what the evidence is. The court found this a clear constitutional violation and ruled that owners should be able to contest these seizures within two weeks. Then, in a tale that will shock our bibliophile listeners, IJ’s Bob McNamara tells us of what the D.C. Circuit thought of the Library of Congress’s program of forcibly taking books as part of its copyright program, even when the taking of the books had nothing to do with copyright. For years small publishers have been threatened with fines if they don’t turn over books, without any compensation, and even though the books are copyrighted anyway. Many of these books are then literally thrown away. Sound like a taking? The court agrees. There’s also some grumbling about moving books between apartments.

Click here for transcript.

Ingram v. Wayne County

Valancourt Books v. Garland

Culley v. Marshall (pending SCOTUS case)

Baby Ninth book page (with events)

Recent Episodes

Short Circuit 348 | Excessive Fines and the IRS

Is a “fine” a “fine”? No, not at all, and therefore it can’t be “excessive.” At least that’s the IRS’s position. Thankfully that argument was […]

Listen Now

Short Circuit 347 | Election Law Special

With less than two weeks before America’s general election it’s time for our biennial dive into election law! A whirlwind tour of election decisions from […]

Listen Now

Short Circuit 346 | Not My Responsibility

When it comes to the law, it’s the responsibility of the government. After all, that’s why we have a government, right? Well, it seems the […]

Listen Now