December 11, 2014

VICTORY!


Below is a statement from Melinda Haring, activism manager at the Institute for Justice, on today’s statement from the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority, announcing its decision to reverse the condemnation of James Dupree’s Mantua art studio. The city was attempting to forcibly seize James Dupree’s studio through eminent domain in order to replace it with private development.

Today saw an enormous victory for Philadelphia artist James Dupree and his family. James’s victory proves that citizens can fight and beat city hall—even in Philadelphia. James and his family hope to inspire Americans everywhere to stand up whenever their rights are violated.

Dupree lost many years of his work and life fighting this illegal and unconstitutional land grab. James’s victory puts the city of Philadelphia on notice: the city cannot take private property for private development ever again.

The Institute for Justice has led the charge against the illegal land grab, but we would like to salute the ACLU Greater Philadelphia Chapter, ACLU of Pennsylvania, Americans For Prosperity – Pennsylvania, The Center for Emerging Visual Artists, Commonwealth Foundation, Institute of Contemporary Art, Mural Arts Program, Painted Bride Art Center, Property Rights Alliance, Molly Dougherty, Professor Patricia M. Smith and the Rev. Dr. Mark K. Tyler for standing with the Dupree family.

James Dupree is currently in transit but will be available for comment later in the day.

Founded in 1991, the Institute for Justice is the national law firm for liberty. To learn more about IJ’s fight to protect private property nationwide, visit www.ij.org/cases/privateproperty.

Share

More on Private Property

Giant Skeletons in South Milwaukee yard

Private Property

South Milwaukee Orders Residents to Take Down Whimsical Skeleton Display, a Violation of Their First Amendment Rights

Christopher Ingraham · July 7, 2026

Leonard Hoffmann is a North Dakota property owner fighting for fair compensation for property taken by a pipeline company through eminent domain.

Private Property

Ranchers’ Fight for a Fair Price from Pipeline Company that Took Their Land Heads to the US Supreme Court

Andrew Wimer · June 29, 2026

Cathy George was home alone when a SWAT team raided her home looking for a suspect who was already in custody.

Private Property

After Wrongly Raiding Woman’s Home, Government’s Response Only Raises More Questions

Andrew Wimer · June 24, 2026