November 20, 2026

National Law Firm Responds to Pinal County Board of Supervisors Denying Special Use Permit for Local Education Entrepreneur’s Microschool

Woman sitting on a chair in an empty classroom with tables and chairs

PINAL COUNTY, Ariz.—On Wednesday, November 18, the Pinal County Board of Supervisors (BOS) held a meeting andvoted to deny a Special Use Permit to Karli Kemper’s State 48, a local microschool that caters to children with special needs. The county had specifically noted they would not take up the issue until after the Board of Adjustments and Appeals had issued itsinterpretation of “school”. Nevertheless, the BOS proceeded to hold a vote and did not tellKarli. The Institute for Justice (IJ), a national leader in defending educational opportunity representing Karli and State 48, sent the following letter yesterday to Harvey Krauss, the Pinal County Planning Manager, in response. IJ will move forward with the BOA process and will continue to support Karli and her right to operate her microschool. The letter in full is below:

“Mr. Krauss,

We have just been made aware that yesterday the Board of Supervisors acted to deny the State 48’s Special Use Permit, even though we had agreed that the SUP would be considered only after the Board of Adjustment determined the proper interpretation of “school.” Having now read the transcript of your presentation to the Board, you clearly recalled that we had agreed to hold this until after the BOA, and recognized that (not surprisingly) that the applicant was not in the room to make their presentation. Nevertheless, the Board went ahead because, in Mr. Vitiello’s opinion it was a “waste of time” to hold consideration because “nothing’s changing.”

This action reflects poorly on the County. It has been bad enough that the County has invented hurdles to the BOA process that are not in the Development Code; there is no requirement of a written interpretation and no procedure by which to obtain one. But for the County to act on the SUP when it knows there was an agreement to have the BOA first make its interpretation, knows that the applicant was not in the room because of that agreement, and to dismiss the opportunity to make a presentation as a waste of time that won’t change anything is simply bad faith and suggests that the County’s procedures are mere facades to hide pre-determined outcomes.

At this point, to head off the need for immediate litigation, we insist that you agree, in writing, that the County will stay any enforcement action against Karli and State 48 pending the BOA’s interpretation. Please let us know by close of business Friday, Nov. 20, whether you agree to stay enforcement.

I also request that you, your department, everyone on this email who works for the County, and the members and staff of the Board of Supervisors, retain all documents and communications regarding State 48, Ms. Kemper and her family, and the SUP application. This includes personal emails, texts, and messaging apps used for such communications.

We are planning to proceed with the BOA process as we had agreed to do. But yesterday’s action by the Board of Supervisors has gone a long way toward guaranteeing that this situation will result in litigation.”

The Institute for Justice is a nonprofit, public-interest law firm that litigates nationwide to vindicate individual liberties. Since IJ’s founding in 1991, it has been the nation’s leading courtroom defender of the right of parents to direct their children’s education, of private property rights, and of economic liberty: the right to earn an honest living free from irrational and arbitrary government regulation. Those three missions intersect in this case. The case is also a part of IJ’s Education Entrepreneurship Project, which is committed to protecting the right of entrepreneurs to offer meaningful alternatives to the public school system and of parents to access those alternatives for their children. By dismantling barriers to innovation, flexibility, and creativity in private education, it ensures that every parent can find the education that will best meet her child’s unique, individual needs.   

#  #  #

To arrange interviews on this subject, journalists may contact Phillip Suderman, IJ’s Communications Project Manager, at [email protected] or (850) 376-4110. More information on the case is available at: https://ij.org/case/pinal-county-microschools/   

Share

More News

Court of Appeals Will Rule on Federal Accountability in Case Involving Detention of Protest Apparel

Phillip Suderman · November 17, 2026

Charles Copley carries his son while hiking a wooded trail with his other child in Roxbury, Connecticut

Other Property Rights Abuses

Connecticut Couple to Resume Renting Trails to Hikers After Town Zoning Officials Fail to Respond to Request for Zoning Interpretation

Dan King · November 10, 2026

Chasidy Deck is a Treasure Valley native who bought a beautiful tiny home to afford living in the Boise area. But she was made homeless because the city of Meridian bans living in tiny homes on private property.

Housing Abundance and Affordability

Idaho Supreme Court: Property Owners Cannot Challenge Meridian’s Ban on Tiny Homes on Wheels

Matt Powers · November 9, 2026