In the course of their duties, law enforcement officers sometimes damage property belonging to innocent individuals. The damage could be as minor as a fence broken during a foot chase or as extensive as the destruction of a home where a suspect has barricaded himself. In either case, after the damage is done, the question becomes who pays the bill: the unlucky property owner or the government?
This is the first nationwide study to quantify how often property owners seek compensation from local governments for damage caused by law enforcement—and how often governments honor those requests. Our results show local governments frequently refuse to compensate property owners, effectively turning public benefits into private burdens—even though they could easily afford to make worthy owners whole.
Additional Downloads
Key Findings
$1,260
The median value of a property damage claim in our data was $1,260—more than most Americans have in their emergency funds.
60% / 41%
Municipalities denied 60% of all claims with known outcomes and 41% of claims where the property owners were innocent bystanders.
$6,500
If municipalities paid every claim in our dataset, the average cost would have been only about $6,500 a year—a tiny fraction of their annual spending.
Press Release
Check out this report's press release and contact our media team member for additional information.
Related Cases
Immunity and Accountability | Private Property | SWAT Destruction
Innocent Family Seeks to Hold SWAT Team Accountable for Raiding the Wrong Home
A North Carolina family is seeking to hold SWAT teams accountable for raiding the wrong home in April 2024.
Immunity and Accountability | Other Property Rights Abuses | Private Property | SWAT Destruction
A Police Raid Wrecked Her Home; Now a South Bend Mom Fights for Compensation
In South Bend, a SWAT team raided the wrong home, leaving a single mom with thousands of dollars in damage not covered by insurance. She is suing for compensation.
Immunity and Accountability | Private Property | SWAT Destruction
Innocent Small Business Owner Seeks Compensation After Shop Destroyed by SWAT Team
For thirty years, Carlos Pena ran a print shop in North Hollywood. His world was turned upside down, however, in August 2022, when a fugitive forced his way into Carlos’s shop and barricaded himself inside…