December 20, 2023

FEDERAL JUDGE HANDS FREE-SPEECH VICTORY TO RETIRED ENGINEER

Court holds that state officials violated the First Amendment when they ordered retired engineer Wayne Nutt to stop talking about math in public

ARLINGTON, Va.—Today, Chief Judge Richard Myers issued an opinion holding that the North Carolina Board of Examiners for Engineers and Surveyors violated the First Amendment when it ordered retired engineer Wayne Nutt to stop expressing opinions about engineering without a state license. Nutt, represented by the Institute for Justice (IJ), filed the lawsuit after the Board sent him a series of threatening letters ordering him to stop publicly offering opinions about engineering without a license, on pain of potential criminal punishment. Today’s ruling confirms that those letters—and the law they were based on—violate the First Amendment.

“State licensing boards nationwide increasingly act as if they are boards of censors, deciding who may or may not speak about the topics they regulate,” explained IJ Attorney Joe Gay. “Today’s ruling is a powerful reminder that in this country we rely on people to decide who they want to listen to. We don’t rely on government boards to decide who gets to speak.”

Wayne’s case began after the Board discovered he was using his decades of experience as a working engineer to offer opinions about the designs of public works. That speech, according to the Board, was punishable as a misdemeanor unless Wayne (a retiree in his 70s) obtained a professional engineer’s license from the state. Wayne sued, sparking nationwide controversy—including a viral YouTube video that has been viewed over two million times. And, today, he was vindicated.

The court’s opinion makes clear that the case turns on basic free-speech principles: “At its core, this case concerns the extent to which a law-abiding citizen may use his technical expertise to offer a dissenting perspective against the government,” the opinion says. “Stating that dissent required the speaker to use his expertise in several ways. He had to do some math. He had to apply recognized methodologies. He even had to write a report memorializing his work. Some of that work may plausibly be considered conduct. But it ends up providing him the basis to speak his mind.”

“This is a win for more than just me,” said Wayne. “There are a lot of people in the same situation—people who have expertise that they’ve been blocked from talking about. This decision is an affirmation that the First Amendment protects all of our rights to share what we know.”

“The First Amendment protects everyone’s right to speak their minds, whether they’re talking about politics or talking about math,” explained IJ Deputy Director of Litigation Robert McNamara. “Regulators often seem to forget that basic fact, but we always stand ready to remind them.”

#  #  #

To arrange interviews on this subject, journalists may contact Phillip Suderman, IJ’s Communications Project Manager at [email protected] (850) 376-4110. More information on the case is available a: https://ij.org/case/nc-engineering-speech/

Share

More on First Amendment

Gavel resting on stacked hundred-dollar bills and coin stacks, symbolizing fines and financial penalties

First Amendment

National Law Firm Warns Maine Town: Fines for Autistic Girl’s Lawn Ornaments Violate the First Amendment

Christopher Ingraham · October 5, 2026

IJ’s appellate court victory for Lauren Richwine, an Indiana 'death doula' giving advice to the dying and their loved ones, is another sign IJ’s pioneering stance on occupational speech is winning over judges.

First Amendment

Fort Wayne Death Doula Secures Final Victory in First Amendment Lawsuit Challenging State’s Restrictions on Discussing End-of-Life Care

Dan King · June 11, 2026

Don Fletcher, Ashley Fore, Sherry Digmon, and Cindy Jackson suffered were charged with bogus crimes by the Escambia County, Alabama district attorney and sheriff. They are suing over the retaliatory arrests.

First Amendment

Lawsuit Against Alabama District Attorney and Sheriff Who Punished Political Opponents and Reporter Moves Forward

Andrew Wimer · March 26, 2026